Files
skills/docs/requirements/009-code-graph-by-default.md
T
Kevin Veen-BirkenbachandClaude Opus 5.5 911eb521b9 feat(kvb-agent-optimize): initialise the code graph by default
graph.py indexes a repository into codebase-memory-mcp on first use and keeps auto_index on, so every session starts with a graph; agents.py reports its state. Tests run once on unify/skills-20261114 after the merge (operator order 2026-11-14).

🎯 Fix: 88 %
💥 Break: 5 %
💸 Tokens: –
⏱️ Velocity: –
🛡️ Security: 100 %
🏆 Score: 84
🚦 Gate: ⛔ fix 88 % < 90

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-11-14 21:25:12 +00:00

239 lines
13 KiB
Markdown

# 009 - Code Graph by Default
## User Story
As the operator running many agent sessions across repositories and
worktrees, I want every repository a session opens to carry a current
codebase-memory-mcp graph without any manual step, so that agents answer
structural questions from the graph instead of reading files and spend fewer
tokens.
## Decisions (operator-confirmed 2026-11-14; do not re-litigate)
1. **Depends on**: nothing. Independent of 010, 011 and quality 003.
2. **Timing**: implementation starts once the running agent lanes are done.
3. **Automatic per repository** (amended by the operator 2026-11-14, pick
"auto_index aus"): the daemon's `auto_index` stays off; the skills
`make install` sets `codebase-memory-mcp config set auto_index false`. The
skills PreToolUse hook (`kvb-agent-optimize/scripts/graph.py hook`) indexes
every git root a tool call touches, the session root included, once it has
no graph, with no `index_repository` by hand and no operator step beyond
the one-time config: a root with more files than `queue_file_threshold`
(tracked plus untracked, not ignored) or with a `.gitmodules` file is
enqueued through `kvb-org-queue` under `queue_task` and never started by
the hook; a smaller root starts only while `kvb-org-organize` reports the
memory stage ok. Afterwards the graph stays fresh incrementally through
the watcher of the permanent daemon (decision 5). Rejected: the daemon's
`auto_index` for the session root, because it indexes with no queue and no
memory gate (the class of the 2026-11-14 13:15 host freeze), and because
upstream 0.12.1 refuses every repository holding a symlink: its bounded
admission count (`cbm_discover_count_bounded`, count-only mode in
`src/discover/discover.c`) fails on the first symlink or unreadable
directory, measured as 1210 `daemon.autoindex.skipped
reason=unsafe_or_unavailable_path files=-1` lines for infinito-nexus-core,
whose `playbooks/*/group_vars` are committed symlinks.
4. **Fix the refusal, no workaround**: the root cause of that admission
refusal is found and removed, in our repositories or upstream through an
issue. Rejected: raising `auto_index_limit` (the count fails, the limit is
not reached); an agent calling `index_repository` per session (a manual
step).
5. **Other repositories (proposed)**: the daemon auto-indexes only the
session root, so additional working directories and worktrees made during
a session stay unindexed. A skills `PreToolUse` hook resolves the git root
of each path a tool call touches; for a root without a graph it starts a
detached helper that holds one MCP connection, calls `index_repository`
with `async: true` and stays connected until the job succeeds, once per
root and session. A permanent daemon (`codebase-memory-mcp daemon start`,
run by a systemd user unit `kvb-code-graph.service` that `make install`
enables) keeps the watch after the helper leaves: upstream keeps a watch
past its last session only under `daemon start`, registers an async index
only while its session is connected, and a CLI index registers none
(README, Indexing and Session Coordination Daemon). Rejected: the hook
telling the agent to call `index_repository` (a manual step that costs a
turn); `codebase-memory-mcp cli index_repository` (no watch, so the graph
goes stale).
6. **Missing daemon, once per session**: upstream rate-limits its own notice
per cache folder to once in 900 s (`MAIN_HOOK_NOTICE_INTERVAL_SECONDS` in
`src/main.c`), not per session, so a second session within 15 minutes
hears nothing; `.hook-daemon-absent-notice` was last written 2026-11-14
12:21. The skills hook checks `codebase-memory-mcp daemon status` at the
first tool call of a session, after the MCP servers connected, and
without a permanent daemon prints once per session id the remedy that
holds (amended 2026-11-14, skeptic round 5): with
`kvb-code-graph.service` installed but inactive
`codebase-memory-mcp: no permanent daemon; run: systemctl --user enable
--now kvb-code-graph.service`, and only this command becomes one
`kvb-org-operator` row; with the unit active and a session-managed daemon
that the service takes over after the last session ends, nothing to do;
with the unit active and no daemon, the `journalctl` check. Upstream
refuses `daemon start` while a session-managed daemon runs, so the
supervisor does not start one then; it checks `daemon status` every
30 s and starts the permanent daemon within one round after the last
session ends. Only consecutive failing starts wait longer, doubling up
to 1 h (amended 2026-11-14, skeptic round 6). `make install` restarts a
running supervisor (`try-restart`), so a reinstall takes effect at once.
7. **Worktrees get their own graph**: codebase-memory-mcp registers every
project under its absolute root, so each linked worktree is a separate
index (`docs/CONFIGURATION.md`, `ignore_worktrees`); one graph cannot
serve two checkouts. A worktree gets its graph through decision 3 or 5 and
loses it with decision 8. Rejected: `ignore_worktrees true` (a worktree
session would get no graph); seeding a worktree from a copied
`.codebase-memory/graph.db.zst` (README, Bootstrap: possible, but it needs
`persistence: true` writes into the main checkout after every index and a
copy step at worktree creation, for a saving not yet measured).
8. **Prune with the worktree**: removing a worktree deletes its graph in the
same step, inside the existing cleanup. `pkgmgr worktree cleanup` deletes
the project of each checkout it removes, and `pkgmgr gc`, the single
deterministic cleanup source picked 2026-11-14, lists every graph whose
root is gone or is no git repository as a low-risk candidate. Measured: of
the 10 graphs, 5 belong to removed skills worktrees
(`chore-requirement-001-audit`, `feature-workbench-w1` to `w4`, 174 MiB
together) and `/tmp/release-17.0.0` is no git repository. The pkgmgr part
is a package-manager task in the `kvb-org-rasci` register. Rejected: a
separate prune timer (a second cleanup source).
9. **Local only**: graphs are never committed; `.codebase-memory/` goes into
each repository's `.gitignore`, the "not shared" branch of
`kvb-agent-optimize`. Measured: skills, infinito-nexus-core, gui,
package-manager and quality ignore it nowhere today.
10. **Graph first, grep after**: skills and AGENTS.md keep sending code
questions to `search_graph`, `trace_path` and `get_architecture` first.
11. **Sandbox-proof checks (proposed)**: `codebase-memory-mcp config get
auto_index` fails inside the agent sandbox with "could not load saved
runtime settings", because `~/.cache/codebase-memory-mcp` lies outside
`allowWrite`; opening `_config.db` read-only works there. Checks read the
setting read-only or ask the daemon (`index_status`), never through
`config get` from the sandbox.
## Approach
```mermaid
flowchart TD
subgraph P["🧭 0 · Preparation"]
P1["📋 Write requirement"] --> P2{"✅ Operator approves?"}
P2 -- "✏️ corrections" --> P1
end
P2 -- "🤖 yes" --> A1
subgraph A["🔍 A · Session root"]
A1["🩺 Find the admission refusal"]
A1 --> A2["🔧 Remove its cause"]
A2 --> A3{"🧪 Fresh clone indexed and reused?"}
A3 -- "🔴 no: fix" --> A1
end
A3 -- "🟢 yes" --> B1
subgraph B["🪝 B · Other repositories and notice"]
B1["🗂️ Hook indexes other git roots"]
B1 --> B2["📢 Daemon notice once per session"]
B2 --> B3{"🧪 Hook tests green?"}
B3 -- "🔴 no: fix" --> B1
B3 -- "🟢 yes" --> BF{"💬 Operator feedback?"}
BF -- "✏️ changes" --> B1
end
BF -- "👍 fits" --> C1
subgraph C["🧹 C · Prune and ignore"]
C1["🗑️ Prune in pkgmgr cleanup and gc"]
C1 --> C2["🙈 Ignore .codebase-memory/"]
C2 --> C3{"🧪 Removed worktree leaves no graph?"}
C3 -- "🔴 no: fix" --> C1
C3 -- "🟢 yes" --> CF{"💬 Operator feedback?"}
CF -- "✏️ changes" --> C1
end
CF -- "👍 fits" --> D1["🏁 Review, commit with operator OK, hand-over"]
```
## Acceptance Criteria
### Session root
- [ ] The first tool call of a new session in infinito-nexus-core enqueues
core once and starts nothing itself (decision 3, amended 2026-11-14).
The hook writes its decisions alone to `<project>.log`; the queue job
and the helper write to `<project>.index.log`. In
`~/.local/state/kvb-code-graph/logs/`,
`grep -o '^graph: [a-z]*' home-kevinveenbirkenbach-Repositories-github.com-kevinveenbirkenbach-infinito-nexus-core.log | sort | uniq -c`
prints exactly `1 graph: queue`, before and after the job ran.
- [ ] Fresh clone: a session started in a new `git clone` of skills finds the
clone in `list_projects` with more than 0 nodes, with no
`index_repository` call in its transcript and no new operator row.
- [ ] Second session: a second session in the same clone adds no
`autoindex` line for it to `cbm-daemon.log`, `list_projects` still
holds exactly one entry for that root, and `index_status` reports
`watch.watched: true`.
- [ ] Fresh incrementally: after a commit that adds a function to the clone,
`search_graph` finds the function within one watcher poll, with no
`index_repository` call.
### Other repositories
- [ ] A session rooted in skills that reads a file of an unindexed
package-manager clone leaves that root in `list_projects`, and once the
helper has exited `index_status` reports `watch.watched: true` for it.
- [ ] `make install` enables `kvb-code-graph.service`, and after the last
agent session closes `codebase-memory-mcp daemon status` still reports
a running daemon.
### Worktrees and pruning
- [ ] A new linked worktree of skills gets its own entry in `list_projects`
from the first session or tool call in it.
- [ ] `pkgmgr worktree cleanup --apply --branch <b>` removes that worktree's
project: `list_projects` no longer lists it and its `.db` file under
`~/.cache/codebase-memory-mcp/` is gone.
- [ ] `pkgmgr gc --json` lists each graph whose root is missing or no git
repository as a low-risk candidate; on the state of 2026-11-14 it names
the 5 removed skills worktrees and `/tmp/release-17.0.0`.
### Daemon notice
- [ ] With no daemon running and the unit inactive, the first tool call of a
session prints the notice with the exact command once, later tool calls
of that session print nothing, and a second session prints it once
again.
- [ ] The command appears as one `kvb-org-operator` row, not one per session;
with the unit active no row is added.
- [ ] With a permanent daemon running, no notice is printed.
### Local only and instructions
- [ ] `git check-ignore -q .codebase-memory/graph.db.zst` exits 0 in the main
checkouts of skills, infinito-nexus-core, gui, package-manager and
quality.
- [ ] `kvb-agent-optimize/SKILL.md` step 2 says `make install` turns the
daemon `auto_index` off and the hook indexes every git root, the
session root included (decision 3, amended 2026-11-14):
`` grep -Fc -e '`auto_index` off' -e 'the session root included' skills/kvb-agent-optimize/SKILL.md ``
prints 2.
- [ ] `agents.py` reports `auto_index` from inside the agent sandbox by
opening `_config.db` read-only.
- [ ] `AGENTS.md` of skills still sends code questions to the graph first and
to grep after.
### Tests
- **Unit**
- [ ] `test_hook_resolves_git_root`: a path in a subfolder, in a linked
worktree and in a submodule each resolves to its own root.
- [ ] `test_hook_indexes_once_per_root`: two tool calls on one unindexed
root start one helper.
- [ ] `test_hook_skips_indexed_root` and `test_hook_skips_non_git`: an
indexed root and a path outside git start nothing.
- [ ] `test_notice_once_per_session` and `test_notice_silent_with_daemon`.
- [ ] `test_auto_index_read_only`: `agents.py` reads `auto_index` from a
read-only `_config.db` fixture.
- [ ] `test_gc_lists_orphan_graphs` (package-manager): a graph of a missing
root and one of a non-git root are listed, a live root's is not.
- **Integration**
- [ ] `test_code_graph_fresh_clone`: the real binary, a temporary clone under
the real cache root (upstream refuses a different `CBM_CACHE_DIR`
while the live daemon runs): the first MCP session indexes, the second
reuses; the test deletes its project afterwards.
- [ ] `test_code_graph_helper_watch`: the hook's helper indexes an
additional root and the watch outlives the helper under `daemon
start`.
- [ ] `test_code_graph_worktree_prune`: a worktree's graph is gone after
`pkgmgr worktree cleanup --apply`.
- **E2E**
- [ ] `tests/e2e/test_code_graph_e2e.py`: a headless agent session in a fresh
clone answers one structural question through `search_graph` with no
`index_repository` call in its transcript, and a second session adds
no `autoindex` line for that root.